ASX 24 or CME: Where the Real Liquidity Is for an Australian Trader
Australia has its own futures exchange and it opens while you are awake. That is a real argument. Here is where it wins, where CME is untouchable, and how to tell which one your strategy needs.
You are in Sydney, or Perth, or somewhere in between, and the contract on your chart settles in Chicago. Sooner or later somebody asks the obvious question: why is an Australian routing everything through an American exchange when Australia has its own futures market, quoting in Australian dollars, open while you are actually awake?
It is a fair question and it deserves a straight answer rather than a slogan. ASX 24 and CME are not really fighting over the same customer. One of them owns Australian interest rates and Australian electricity, and nothing on the planet substitutes for it. The other owns global equity index volume, and there it is not close. Which one belongs on your screen depends on what you are trying to trade and how big your account is. Here is the comparison, contract by contract, with the numbers you can check yourself.
What ASX 24 actually is
ASX Limited runs two separate trading platforms and people mix them up constantly. ASX Trade is the sharemarket: equities, ETFs and exchange traded options over single stocks. ASX 24 is the futures market, the old Sydney Futures Exchange under a newer name, and it is where every futures contract listed in Australia trades. ASX describes it in its own words as being open 24 hours a day, six days a week, and home to some of Australia's most established and liquid derivative products.
The product families on the ASX derivatives market break down into four blocks: interest rate derivatives over Australian and New Zealand rates, commodity derivatives (electricity for Australia and New Zealand, natural gas, environmental products and grain), index derivatives over the S&P/ASX indices, and equity derivatives. Clearing goes through ASX Clear (Futures). The whole thing sits under ASIC, which licenses the market operator and every broker that gives you access to it.
That is a real exchange with real products. It is not a toy. What it is not is a global equity index venue, and that distinction is the entire article.
The index contract that does not fit a small account
The flagship Australian index future is the SPI 200, a future over the S&P/ASX 200. Its multiplier is A$25 per index point, and the minimum price movement is one full index point, so one tick is A$25. Confirm the current specification on the ASX contract page before you trade it, because specs do get revised, but that is the shape of the thing.
Now do the arithmetic that matters. A ten point stop on one SPI 200 contract is A$250 of risk. A twenty point stop is A$500. If your rule is that no single trade risks more than one percent of the account, one SPI 200 contract with a modest stop implies an account in the tens of thousands of dollars before you have placed a single order. There is a Mini SPI listed alongside it precisely to cut that ticket down, and ASX publishes its multiplier in the contract specification, but the mini has never carried anything like the volume of the full size contract.
Compare that with what CME lists:
| Contract | Venue | Multiplier | Minimum tick | Value of one tick |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPI 200 (AP) | ASX 24 | A$25 per index point | 1.00 point | A$25.00 |
| E-mini S&P 500 (ES) | CME | US$50 per index point | 0.25 point | US$12.50 |
| Micro E-mini S&P 500 (MES) | CME | US$5 per index point | 0.25 point | US$1.25 |
| E-mini Nasdaq-100 (NQ) | CME | US$20 per index point | 0.25 point | US$5.00 |
| Micro Nasdaq-100 (MNQ) | CME | US$2 per index point | 0.25 point | US$0.50 |
The gap is not subtle. One tick on the SPI 200 costs the same as twenty ticks on the MES and fifty on the MNQ. For someone learning to execute a system, that difference is not a detail, it is the difference between being able to take a full stop loss twenty times in a row while you calibrate and blowing a quarter of the account doing the same thing.
There is a second effect that nobody mentions. With a one point minimum tick, the SPI 200 gives you a coarse grid. You cannot express a stop at a level between two whole points. On the micros the grid is four times finer per point and the point itself is worth a fraction of the money, so your stop can sit exactly where the structure says it should rather than where the tick size lets it.
Hours that suit you and hours that suit the volume
Here is where the local venue earns its keep. ASX 24 runs a day session across the Australian business day and a night session that covers the European and American hours, and ASX publishes the exact session states, product by product, on its trading hours and calendar page. If you want to trade at eleven in the morning in Melbourne, the local index and rate futures are awake and so is the local flow.
CME runs almost continuously too. The electronic session opens Sunday at 17:00 Chicago time and runs to Friday at 16:00, with a sixty minute halt every day between 16:00 and 17:00 Chicago time. So the contract is technically available all through your day. The problem is not availability, it is where the volume sits.
CME equity index volume is concentrated in the American cash session. The US equity open at 08:30 Chicago time lands at 23:30 in Sydney during Australian standard time and 01:30 during Australian daylight time. That is the hour when the book is deepest, the spread is one tick and size actually rests at each level. During your working day, the same contracts are in the Asian session: still tradable, noticeably thinner, and prone to the kind of drifting range that punishes a momentum system built on the US open.
So the honest framing is this. ASX 24 gives you liquidity at a civilised hour in a contract that is too big for a small account. CME gives you a contract sized for a small account with world class liquidity at an hour when you should be asleep. Pick your poison, and pick it deliberately rather than by accident.
Where ASX 24 is simply better, and it is not close either
If your interest is Australian interest rates, this is not a debate. The 3 Year and 10 Year Treasury Bond futures are the instruments the entire Australian fixed income market uses to hedge and to express duration views. The 90 Day Bank Bill and the 30 Day Interbank Cash Rate futures are the front end. The ASX RBA Rate Indicator, the thing every journalist quotes on the morning of a Reserve Bank decision, is calculated straight off the 30 Day Interbank Cash Rate futures. There is no CME contract that does that job for Australia. None.
Same story for electricity. Australian and New Zealand electricity futures exist on ASX 24 and nowhere else that matters. Same for the grain complex: wheat, barley and canola priced in Australian dollars for people who actually grow the stuff. Same for the New Zealand rate curve.
Notice what these have in common. They are all contracts whose underlying risk is Australian. When the risk is local, the local exchange is the deepest pool in the world for it, because the natural hedgers are here. When the risk is global equity beta, the deepest pool is in Chicago, because that is where the natural hedgers of global equity beta happen to clear.
Brokers, and what each route gives you
To trade ASX 24 you need a broker that is a participant of that market or that clears through one. To trade CME from Australia you need a broker with access to CME Globex, which in practice means either an Australian firm with an omnibus arrangement into a US clearing member, or dealing directly with an international futures broker.
A few things to establish before you open anything:
- The licence. Any firm dealing with Australian retail clients in derivatives needs an Australian Financial Services Licence, and you can check it yourself on the ASIC registers. Do it. It takes two minutes and it is the single cheapest piece of due diligence available to you.
- The margin currency. ASX 24 positions are margined in Australian dollars. CME positions are margined in US dollars. Either you fund the account in USD, in which case you carry the conversion once, or the broker converts on the fly and you carry a spread every time. Ask which one you are getting and what the conversion rate is based on.
- The commission structure. Futures commissions are quoted per contract per side. On the micros, the fixed components (exchange fee, clearing fee, regulatory fees, the platform's routing charge) make up a large slice of the total cost, so a headline commission that looks tiny can still leave you paying several dollars a round turn. Ask for the all in number, not the broker's slice.
- Day margin versus initial margin. Some brokers offer reduced intraday margin on liquid CME contracts and some do not. On ASX 24 it is generally the exchange number. This changes how many contracts your account can actually hold.
Data fees, and what you actually need to pay for
Both venues charge for real time data and both give free delayed data. The structures are different enough to catch people out.
CME Group is not one exchange, it is four: CME, CBOT, NYMEX and COMEX. Each carries its own monthly market data subscription. Index micros sit under CME. The Dow contracts and the Treasury futures sit under CBOT. Crude and natural gas sit under NYMEX. Gold, silver and copper sit under COMEX. If your chart layout has MNQ, crude and gold on it, you are buying three subscriptions, not one, and most people discover this on the second invoice. There is also a hard split between non professional and professional status, with the professional rate several times higher, and status is not a matter of how good you are: it depends on things like whether you are licensed, whether the account is in a company name and whether anyone else pays for the data. CME publishes the current rates and the definitions through its market data section, and your broker collects the declaration.
ASX charges its own market data fees for ASX 24 depth and top of book, and Australian brokers bundle them in very different ways. Some include a basic feed in the platform fee, some pass through everything. Ask before you sign, because a data bill that turns up quarterly and is denominated per platform per exchange can quietly exceed your commission spend if you trade a handful of contracts a week.
Currency and tax, the quiet differences
An Australian dollar contract has one clean property: your profit and loss is already in the currency you live in. Trade a USD denominated CME contract and every position is implicitly two positions, the index and the Australian dollar against the US dollar. If the AUD moves two percent against you over a month, that shows up in the Australian dollar value of your account even on days you did not trade.
That flows through to the paperwork. Amounts have to be reported to the Australian Taxation Office in Australian dollars, which means translating USD results at the appropriate rate, and the more transactions you have the more that matters. The bigger question, and the one worth taking to an accountant rather than a forum, is whether your activity is on revenue account or capital account. Active intraday futures trading is commonly treated as ordinary income rather than as a capital gain, which also means the CGT discount that people assume applies to investments generally does not help you. The ATO sets out the framework for capital gains tax on assets and the tests for whether you are carrying on a business, and the answer genuinely differs from one trader to the next.
This is the local venue's second real advantage, alongside the hours. An AUD contract with an Australian broker produces a simpler set of records than a USD contract with an offshore one. Simpler is not the same as cheaper, but if you hate paperwork it is worth something.
How to choose without a slogan
Strip out the loyalty and the marketing and it comes down to four questions.
- What risk are you actually trading? Australian rates, Australian power or Australian grain: ASX 24, no argument. Global equity index, crude, gold: CME.
- How big is the account? Below roughly the point where A$250 of stop loss is a reasonable single trade risk, the SPI 200 is not a serious option and the micros are.
- When can you sit down? If you can only trade during Australian business hours and you want a deep book, the local venue deserves a hard look. If you can trade the US open, the deepest book on earth is available to you.
- How much friction can you tolerate? AUD margin, AUD statements and a local broker is the low friction path. USD margin, per exchange data fees and translated tax records is the price of access to CME volume.
Most Australian traders running an intraday index system end up on CME micros, and the reason is contract size before anything else. That is not a knock on ASX 24. Put an Australian rates trader in front of the same two menus and the choice inverts completely.
This article is general information about how these two markets are structured, not financial, tax or legal advice, and it is not a recommendation to trade any particular contract. Leveraged futures can lose you more than you deposit, contract specifications and fees change, and your own tax position depends on facts specific to you, so check the current details with the exchange and take advice from a licensed Australian professional before you act.
Educational content, not investment advice. Trading futures involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for every investor. Any reference to Algomyth results is hypothetical, simulated over historical data, and shown in full on the performance page; past performance does not guarantee future results.
Take the seat: watch the engines live
Three specialist engines on Nasdaq, S&P and Gold, every signal streamed the moment it happens, with the stop and the target written before the trade. From $149 a month per market.


